The newest registered user is Karly
Our users have posted a total of 205242 messages in 32019 subjects
Solid Coaches
Page 1 of 3 • 1, 2, 3
Solid Coaches
My daughter isn't a LH D1 player but I would obviously like to give her every opportunity at developing into that.
I'm sure this may be a question a lot of parents are wondering, so please give us names for coaches anywhere in DFW!
Thanks
FowlerRules- TxSoccer Lurker
- Posts : 4
Points : 3912
Join date : 2014-03-09
Re: Solid Coaches
Plus the parents & girls are wonderful.
lovesoccer- TxSoccer Postmaster
- Posts : 251
Points : 5380
Join date : 2010-11-14
Re: Solid Coaches
Volpratt- TxSoccer Lurker
- Posts : 5
Points : 3910
Join date : 2014-03-10
Re: Solid Coaches
Guest- Guest
Re: Solid Coaches
Re: Solid Coaches
Unfortunately, that is usually not the case. Most of the players on those top teams developed somewhere else before being asked to play with that team. Rarely does a coach of a top team need to develop players. Not when they can replace players with someone who can make an immediate impact.
In my experience you need to look at what the coach has accomplished with other teams. That is not a reference to which division the team plays in, but instead how that team progressed year over year.
Example:
Team makes DIII the first year
Team finishes top 2 in DIII and moves to DII second year
Team finishes top 5 of DII and gets promoted to DI when 5 teams leave for ECNL
By tracking a coach and team's progress over one age group you will be able to get a decent idea of how that them has grown and developed but if you go back and find other teams with the same coach you will be able to find a pattern. You will also see that several of the coaches who supposedly develop players will have teams in the same divisions year in and year out across several different age groups with no real progress. That might be a good indicator that the coach is not as strong at developing as one might suggest.
Last edited by Armanji on 11/03/14, 01:00 pm; edited 1 time in total
Oscar- TxSoccer Poster
- Posts : 27
Points : 3932
Join date : 2014-03-10
Re: Solid Coaches
Armanji wrote:There is a misconception that the way to get the best coaching is to join one of the top few teams and your daughter will develop into a top player.
Unfortunately, that is usually not the case. Most of the players on those top teams developed somewhere else before being asked to play with that team. Rarely does a coach of a top team need to develop players. Not when they can replace players with someone who can make an immediate impact.
In my experience you need to look at what the coach has accomplished with other teams. That is not a referrence to which division the team playes in, but instead how that team progressed year over year.
Example:
Team makes DIII the first year
Team finishes top 2 in DIII and moves to DII second year
Team finishes top 5 of DII and gets promoted to DI when 5 teams leave for ECNL
By tracking a coach and team's progress over one age group you will be able to get a decent idea of how that theam has grown and developed but if you go back and find other teams with the same coach you will be able to find a pattern. You will also see that several of the coaches who supposedly develop players will have teams in the same divisions year in and year out across several different age groups with no real progress. That might be a good indicator that the coach is not as strong at developing as one might suggest.
How do you know if the coach has accomplished this via "developing" players vs. recruiting and roster churn?
You still need the eyeball test and word-of-mouth.
Guest- Guest
Re: Solid Coaches
Oscar- TxSoccer Poster
- Posts : 27
Points : 3932
Join date : 2014-03-10
Re: Solid Coaches
Armanji wrote:If you do not make it out to a game and watch how the coach's team performs, and instead your beleive everything you read on the internet then you deserve whichever coach you choose.
Best post in this type of thread I think I've ever read.
Re: Solid Coaches
Ok, so you go and watch a game, AND YES EVERYONE SHOULD, but as was asked... you are watching a game.. how do you know if he developed them or recuited them. What you are watching is a game... Games should be seen, but ill take a practice sessions over games. How is instruction given, what instruction is given, demeanor with the players, etc...Armanji wrote:If you do not make it out to a game and watch how the coach's team performs, and instead your beleive everything you read on the internet then you deserve whichever coach you choose.
game are for fun and trying what has been taught in practice, which could have been done elsewhere.
Guest- Guest
Re: Solid Coaches
Zizou- TxSoccer Spammer
- Posts : 2433
Points : 6567
Join date : 2013-11-09
Re: Solid Coaches
Zizou- TxSoccer Spammer
- Posts : 2433
Points : 6567
Join date : 2013-11-09
Re: Solid Coaches
Zizou- TxSoccer Spammer
- Posts : 2433
Points : 6567
Join date : 2013-11-09
Re: Solid Coaches
My OP indicated that the top few teams of an age group rarely have to develop players. (Please notice I used the word "rarely") If you do not understand what that word means please look it up.
BWG was simply playing devil's advocate. He did not forget my OP when he asked "How do you know if the coach has accomplished this via "developing" players vs. recruiting and roster churn?".
I am sure he actually read and comprehended that I mentioned "By tracking a coach and team's progress over one age group you will be able to get a decent idea of how that team has grown and developed but if you go back and find other teams with the same coach you will be able to find a pattern."
I gathered he was trying to indicate that research alone was not enough. I agree with him 100% and I responded tongue in cheek with "If you do not make it out to a game and watch how the coach's team performs, and instead your believe everything you read on the internet then you deserve whichever coach you choose."
I believe Borussia is not dumb enough to join a team through online research and/or showing up to watch a game. I personally feel he would allow his daughter to go to a practice before they made a decision. I do not understand why he needed to prove that point for the entire forum to read however maybe he felt others were dumb enough to join a team without going to a practice. Either way, Yes Borussia I agree before joining a team one should probably attend a practice. I just didn’t think I had to announce that, because I sort of felt it was common knowledge.
Oscar- TxSoccer Poster
- Posts : 27
Points : 3932
Join date : 2014-03-10
Re: Solid Coaches
FowlerRules dropped this grenade in the room for a reason. Everyone just needs to walk away.
TatonkaBurger- TxSoccer Addict
- Posts : 1175
Points : 5564
Join date : 2012-12-03
Re: Solid Coaches
FowlerRules- TxSoccer Lurker
- Posts : 4
Points : 3912
Join date : 2014-03-09
Re: Solid Coaches
go99- TxSoccer Spammer
- Posts : 2880
Points : 8278
Join date : 2010-03-02
Location : The Ahole TXsoccer deserves, but not the one it needs right now. So they will hate me. Because I can take it. Because I'm not their hero. I'm a silent guardian, a watchful protector. A dark knight
Re: Solid Coaches
TatonkaBurger wrote:You know that you will never get back the time that it took you write out this play-by-play, right?
FowlerRules dropped this grenade in the room for a reason. Everyone just needs to walk away.
He comes to the board to gain its infinite coaching candidates wisdom, bailing himself out from his own ignorance. Get out from behind your key board and start doing your own research. It will be better for your DD in the long run. Darn, my head hurts!
Zizou- TxSoccer Spammer
- Posts : 2433
Points : 6567
Join date : 2013-11-09
Re: Solid Coaches
Armanji wrote:It never ceases to amaze me how many people will take bits and pieces of a conversation and try to turn it into an argument. It is usually those who feel that their coach or team has been slighted in some way and they have a chip on their shoulder. Please note my original post did not call out any team, coach, or club.
My OP indicated that the top few teams of an age group rarely have to develop players. (Please notice I used the word "rarely") If you do not understand what that word means please look it up.
BWG was simply playing devil's advocate. He did not forget my OP when he asked "How do you know if the coach has accomplished this via "developing" players vs. recruiting and roster churn?".
I am sure he actually read and comprehended that I mentioned "By tracking a coach and team's progress over one age group you will be able to get a decent idea of how that team has grown and developed but if you go back and find other teams with the same coach you will be able to find a pattern."
I gathered he was trying to indicate that research alone was not enough. I agree with him 100% and I responded tongue in cheek with "If you do not make it out to a game and watch how the coach's team performs, and instead your believe everything you read on the internet then you deserve whichever coach you choose."
I believe Borussia is not dumb enough to join a team through online research and/or showing up to watch a game. I personally feel he would allow his daughter to go to a practice before they made a decision. I do not understand why he needed to prove that point for the entire forum to read however maybe he felt others were dumb enough to join a team without going to a practice. Either way, Yes Borussia I agree before joining a team one should probably attend a practice. I just didn’t think I had to announce that, because I sort of felt it was common knowledge.
If you truly are new to the forum then you assume to much. No one is dumb, but there are plenty of newbies and thise swayed by something as meaningless as FBR. Don't assume, the forum is for enlightenment, knowledge, humor, and A holes like me to pass the time! Haha
Guest- Guest
Re: Solid Coaches
Sweet_feet99- TxSoccer Postmaster
- Posts : 385
Points : 4921
Join date : 2012-07-14
Re: Solid Coaches
Wait a second....I think we're talking about practice and games.
FowlerRules- TxSoccer Lurker
- Posts : 4
Points : 3912
Join date : 2014-03-09
Re: Solid Coaches
DrSoccer- TxSoccer Author
- Posts : 532
Points : 6234
Join date : 2009-05-26
Re: Solid Coaches
DrSoccer wrote:You're looking at it wrong. First find good skills coaching. Put in 4-5 1 hour sessions each week either with him or not, (before or after practice or on days off or weekends). Always have your dd warm up with foot skills at home for 30 minutes before leaving for each team practice or game. During the summer find somewhere (camp/coach) where she can practice 2 times a day for 8 weeks. Repeat till she's in HS. Along the way find the best team that your dd can start for and that the coach is not an a-h. As she improves move her to a better team. At U15 its ok if the coach is an a-h. At 16 commit to college. Then sit back and enjoy her jr and sr yr in hs.
What do you do with the other 2 weeks of summer?? And you didn't say anything about playing with 4 teams throughout the academy career. Also, why only 1-hour sessions with the skills coach?
dadof3- TxSoccer Addict
- Posts : 1033
Points : 6011
Join date : 2012-07-16
Location : McKinney
Page 1 of 3 • 1, 2, 3
» Coppell FC 97 - Looking for One More Solid Player
» Need a solid guest player?
» Andromeda FC 97 Girls (Coach Krys Sobieski) looking too add to our roster
» Heather O'Reilly--Very Solid Listen