Kickball and South Texas

I noticed something this weekend at the Challenge Shootout tournament. When I walked by the '06 and '07 age groups, they were doing something so unusual I stopped to ask about it...

There was a "build out line" about 30 yards from the goal line. Every time the keeper had the ball (either a goal kick or secured it with their hands), the other team had to retreat behind the build out line. No punting or long goal kicks were allowed. The keeper was supposed to wait for the other team to retreat, and then would play the ball wide to a full back, and then once the first touch was taken, the defending team could cross the line and press.

What was unusual was how I saw teams play. Every single South Texas team I saw (maybe 4-5 different ones) would play the ball wide to the full back, then attempt to connect short or medium range passes to feet to escape their own third. Every single North Texas team I saw (maybe 3-4 different ones...mostly Sting and D'Feeters) would play the ball wide to a full back, who would then immediately kick the ball as far as they could (or the keeper would just set the ball at their feet - since punting wasn't allowed - and kick it as far as they could). I thought the way the South Texas teams were trying to play was fantastic to watch. It didn't always work, and they'd turn the ball over in their own half about as often as they'd escape, but they were all legitimately trying to play out of the back.

Is the reason that North Texas teams just booted it far because these rules are unusual to us and we simply aren't used to them, or are North Texas rules the same at these ages and we just choose to boot it long because that's more likely to be a winning strategy at these younger ages?

The pit outdoor league in Plano also has the same line and rules. Depending on the coach it is sometimes used effectively and so.etimes ignored a d the ball still booted as far as the keeper can kick it.

"I'm not here to develop you, I'm here to win"

We were down in Houston at the beginning of the year and had a different experience. In our games the keeper would play the ball outside of the box and the defender would quickly play the ball to the midfielder sitting on the sideline. The midfielder would then quickly kick the ball as far as possible down the middle of the field as there is no offsides so long as you are in front of the build out line.

I left wondering is this what US Soccer envisioned when they created these rules.

But if every NTX team played the ball out and didn't use the ol' Bootball......

What catch phrase would those teams/coaches use, when they couldn't advertise:  "We play Possession ball style"

Just-a-Keeper wrote:We were down in Houston at the beginning of the year and had a different experience. In our games the keeper would play the ball outside of the box and the defender would quickly play the ball to the midfielder sitting on the sideline. The midfielder would then quickly kick the ball as far as possible down the middle of the field as there is no offsides so long as you are in front of the build out line.

I left wondering is this what US Soccer envisioned when they created these rules.

Wondering if maybe the South Texas teams in the time since your experience in January - having had another 3 months of "development" - now are able to do it more properly? Maybe your take on things in January (ugly) and my take on things this week (I wouldn't quite call it pretty, but it was at least in the ballpark) is even MORE reason to implement it?

If what we're both saying is true, Just-a-Keeper, then the purpose for why I imagine the rule was implemented (start teaching how to play out of the back and stop encouraging the kid with the biggest foot to "kick it super far to the big fast girl up top") is working exactly as intended for STX.

So if the PIT plays this way, does that mean this rule isn't a universal rule for all leagues (LH or JDL)? I left convinced that it should be. At least until the ages (U12, right?) when they can start heading the ball.

Well my disclaimer...I am no rules expert nor do I have a desire to research this.

It is my understanding the build out line, no punting, no throw ins are all part of the US Soccer rules that passed when AP was passed.  If memory serves me correctly US Soccer implemented a date for all sanctioning bodies to comply.  South Texas (or at least Houston) chose to begin implementing the rules immediately.  So yes these teams have had 6 months to adapt and adjust but most importantly it is up to the coaches to teach and educate our youth.  I am sure you will still find teams/coaches who teach the kickball method down south just as there are those coaches here up north.  

We played in San Antonio a few weeks ago and only the academy age groups were playing the build out line...so who knows what is going on down south.

Just-a-Keeper wrote:Well my disclaimer...I am no rules expert nor do I have a desire to research this.

It my understanding the build out line, no punting, no throw ins are all part of the US Soccer rules that passed when AP was passed. If memory serves me correctly US Soccer implemented a date for all sanctioning bodies to comply. South Texas (or at least Houston) chose to begin implementing the rules immediately. So yes these teams have had 6 months to adapt and adjust but most importantly it is up to the coaches to teach and educate our youth. I am sure you will still find teams/coaches who teach the kickball method down south just as there are those coaches here up north.

We played in San Antonio a few weeks ago and only the academy she groups were playing the build out line...so who knows what is going on down south.

I do remember that now. So will the US Soccer rules for younger ages be implemented everywhere beginning this fall? Will LH and JDL put them in place, or will they do their own thing?

Attached are the initiatives for small sided soccer through U12. This size of the field are ridiculously small, especially for u11 and u12 where a good punt by the goalie or kick by a defender can put the ball completely at the other end of the field to be handled by the other goalkeeper. Makes possession-style soccer a joke. And what kid in academy (u6 through u12) doesn't care about winning or losing. It is why these kids aren't in rec anymore. And to go to a tourney and not have champions...really????

https://usys-assets.ae-admin.com/assets/1/3/PDI%20September%202016%20FINAL1.pdf

Isn't the build-out line only in 7v7 for U-9 & U-10? JDL and LH are for U-11 and older (9v9).

https://www.ussoccer.com/~/media/files/coaches/player-dev-initiatives/pdi-february-2017.pdf?la=en

Nothing wrong with smashing the ball up the field. If Vulture Vic's DD is playing up top it's preferred to smash the ball up to her, so she can...score